September 9, 2025
Reports say that Utah’s cutoff is no higher than 216. Reports from Mississippi now indicate that 213 is the cutoff. I am investigating confusion in New York, because of conflicting reports as to whether 222 has qualified. It appears that the cutoff is 222 or 223, but we should consider it as unconfirmed. Iowa just got narrowed down to 214 or 215. A South Carolinian qualified with 216. A Redditor posted that their principal confirmed Ohio’s cutoff as 219.
AL <= 215 (unconfirmed report of 214)
AR <= 220
AZ <= 218
CA = 224
CT <= 224
DC = 226
GA <= 223
FL = 219
HI >= 219
IA 214 or 215
ID <= 216
IL = 222
IN <= 220
KS <= 218
KY <= 214
LA <= 216
MA 225 or 226
MD = 226
ME <= 216
MI <= 220
MO <= 217
MS = 213
NC <= 220
ND <= 217
NH >= 219
NJ = 225
NY Likely 222 or 223, but conflicting reports
OH = 219
OK = 212
OR >= 219 and <= 222
PA >= 221 and <= 224
SC <= 216
TN = 219 (awaiting second confirmation)
TX = 222
UT <= 216
VA = 224
September 8, 2025
California is confirmed at 224. This time for real. Virginia is now confirmed at 224. We have the first report from Idaho, and New York’s range has been narrowed. Kansas is no higher than 218. South Carolina looks to be no higher than 217. Pennsylvania’s cutoff is 224 or lower. A student in Kentucky qualified with a 214. That would mean an increase of AT MOST 1 point, and would be well under Kentucky’s record high. That’s a bit of good news for students in other states. I received an emailed report from a parent in Michigan, whose student qualified at 221, and she pointed out a Reddit qualifier at 220. A student on Reddit did not qualify with a 218 in New Hampshire, and the same was true of a student with a 220 in PA. A Redditor has posted that a 221 did not qualify in Illinois, which would pin the cutoff at 222.
September 6, 2025
I don’t expect to receive much new information over the weekend. One of the outstanding mysteries is whether or not the Studying Abroad and DC cutoffs have moved to 226, which would also indicate that one of the 50 states has moved to 226. I remain guarded about the reports, but this has been a year where unbelievable things have been true. The latest report is of a Maryland student missing out on Semifinalist at 225.
September 5, 2025
I’ve received word from a New Jersey school that its 224 students did not qualify, while its 225 student did. This would be the biggest news of the cycle, and indicates that College Board broke the scale this year. This may also be why we are seeing added levels of secrecy. NMSC seems to be sending less information to schools this year, so getting final confirmation from each state is more difficult. Crowdsourcing is more important than ever, so please help others by sharing the news that you receive from your school, especially if your score is in the critical zone. Compass will not release your email address, and you are welcome to use a pseudonym. Compass compiles information received directly, information received via this website, and information received via other sources such as Reddit.
If there is bigger news than NJ at 225, it would be word that U.S. Students Studying Abroad could be 226! USSSA is a selection unit that cannot have a cutoff higher than the highest state cutoff. The same is true for DC. If USSSA is 226, then some state also reached 226. Needless to say, this is the mystery I am trying to solve. If there are DC or USSSA students getting news at 225, please reach out.
September 4, 2025: Texas at 222.
Both Compass and Reddit have received reports of California students at 222 not qualifying as Semifinalists. A student on Reddit noted that they did not qualify in IL with a 220. Oklahoma students have qualified at 212 and 213, and we believe the cutoff is 212. A North Carolina student with 220 reported qualifying. We have also had reports of the Texas cutoff moving to 222. This would be a record high, so I am trying to nail it down.
September 2, 2025: Letters arriving at schools. Florida at 219.
National Merit mails Semifinalist notifications directly to high schools and homeschoolers, and those packets have begun to arrive. As we hear from students, we will update this page with the latest information from across the country.
Florida’s Semifinalist cutoff is confirmed at 219, a 2-point increase.
April 7, 2025: Commended cutoff at 210.
The Commended Student cutoff for the class of 2026 is confirmed at a Selection Index of 210. This was the exact level Compass projected in November based on PSAT results. This means that changes to our estimated ranges for Semifinalist cutoffs are minimal. The extreme edges — upper and lower — of our estimated ranges are a bit less probable, but the “Most Likely” scores are unchanged. The fact that Compass’s Commended cutoff estimate was correct, however, does not mean that the Semifinalist projections will prove just as accurate — there is always variability at the state level. Juniors scoring at or above 210 on the PSAT/NMSQT will be Commended Students or Semifinalists, but announcements are not made until September. Semifinalist cutoffs will not be revealed until late August or early September.
November 13: Updated with final wave of PSAT scores.
College Board released scores in three waves depending on when students took the PSAT. We have now received scores summaries for all three waves. It is possible that some late scores will still dribble in, but we are not expecting any changes. The results point to a strong upward trend in cutoffs for the class of 2026. You are welcome to jump to the table of estimates below, but we encourage students and families to read more about how we came to those estimates. For more information on the National Merit Program, in general, you may want to read Compass’s National Merit Scholarship Program Explained. If you want to browse almost two decades’ worth of cutoffs, you can find them in Compass’s National Merit Historical Cutoffs.
What is a Semifinalist Cutoff?
Each year almost 17,000 juniors are named Semifinalists in the National Merit Scholarship Program and continue on in the hopes of being one of the 15,000 Finalists and, eventually, one of the 7,500 scholarship recipients. The score needed to qualify as a Semifinalist varies by state and is known as the “cutoff.” Every student scoring at or above the Semifinalist cutoff qualifies. The cutoff is not based on a student’s overall PSAT score but on the Selection Index. The Selection Index is listed on a student’s PSAT score report. It can be calculated by doubling the ERW score, adding the Math score, and then dividing the sum by 10. For example, a 720 ERW / 730 M would have a Selection Index of (720 x 2 + 730)/10 = 217. For the class of 2025, cutoffs ranged from 208 to 223.
What is a Commended Student Cutoff?
If you performed well on the PSAT but do not qualify as a Semifinalist, you have the opportunity to be named as a Commended Student. Unlike the Semifinalist cutoffs, the Commended cutoff is set nationally. For last year’s class it was 208. Approximately 36,000 students are named Commended Students each year.
Why does Compass believe that we are likely to see cutoffs, as a whole, go up?
College Board releases very little data about score distribution. The number of top scorers is the most critical piece of information that we get this early in the process. While we do not know the number of students scoring at a particular Selection Index, we do know the number of students scoring in the 1400-1520 range, which roughly correlates to Selection Indexes of 210-228. The class of 2026 ranks 4th in the ten years since the PSAT scoring was overhauled, and this year sees the highest ever percentage of top scores. The number of Semifinalists and Commended students are capped, so cutoffs are likely to rise. But not all cutoffs. The numbers we have seen are at the national level and there is always churn at the state level. What we believe, however, is that more cutoffs will go up than down.
There is a good correlation between the 1400-1520 band of students and the Commended Student score. We believe that the Commended cutoff will come in between 209 and 211, with a 210 being most likely. Based on our historical archive of Semifinalist and Commended cutoffs, we believe that the average Semifinalist cutoff will go up this year.
Will I find out my status right away?
No. In fact, students don’t learn of Semifinalist status until September of senior year. Compass tracks data on current year performance and historical records to provides estimates and updates between PSAT score release and the Semifinalist announcements. Last year — the first year of the digital PSAT — saw a noticeable uptick in scores. Only one state — South Dakota — saw a lower cutoff versus the previous year’s. Was this a onetime quirk? Based on early results for the class of 2026, we do not believe that it was. The upward trend — whether due to the new test format, recovery from COVID-era learning loss, or other factors — appears to be continuing.
One mistake students make is thinking that the cutoff for one year will be the same in the next year. Cutoffs change every year, sometimes by as much as 5 or 6 points (granted, that’s unusual). Compass emphasizes an Estimated Range, which is likely to include the ultimate cutoff. Within that range, we do provide our Most Likely. That score represents our best estimate based on the known factors, but there are many unknown factors. Most of our PSAT performance data are for national results. So we can usually peg the Commended cutoff within a point or two. States, however, can move in different directions. More Alaskan students may test this year. Some strong Rhode Island prep schools may have decided to stop offering the PSAT. A COVID outbreak in Montana could mean more students using Alternate Entry and entering the competition using SAT scores. Below is a table that shows how many states in each of the last 17 years saw increases, decreases, or no change. There has never been a year where even half of all state cutoffs remain unchanged.
The chart below divides the 50 states into those that saw increases (blue), those that remained unchanged (gray), and those that saw declines (red).
Historically, a change in cutoff is more likely than not. Over the decade from 2015 – 2024, Semifinalist cutoffs remained unchanged only about one-third of the time.
We believe that a table of results from this class will skew to the right.
Small states have more volatile cutoffs than large states, but there can be surprises across the board. The PSAT had a significant overhaul in scoring in 2017. If we look at the minimum and maximum cutoffs during the 9-year period from then until the class of 2025, we see that the 13 largest states (about 100,000 or more high school graduates) average a 2.8-point differential. New Jersey has a 1-point differential, since its lowest cutoff is 222 and highest is 223. The smallest states (fewer than 30,000 graduates) have a 6.2 point differential. Alaska has been as low as 208 and as high as 217! The medium-sized states average a 5-point difference between minimum and maximum.
Here are Compass’s current estimates for Semifinalist cutoffs for the class of 2026:
State | Class of 2026 Estimated Range | Class of 2026 Most Likely | Class of 2025 (Actual) | Class of 2024 (Actual) | Class of 2023 (Actual) | # of 2025 Semifinalists |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Alabama | 210 - 216 | 214 | 212 | 210 | 212 | 267 |
Alaska | 210 - 216 | 214 | 214 | 209 | 210 | 36 |
Arizona | 215 - 220 | 218 | 217 | 216 | 214 | 401 |
Arkansas | 210 - 215 | 213 | 213 | 210 | 210 | 134 |
California | 220 - 223 | 222 | 221 | 221 | 220 | 2103 |
Colorado | 216 - 221 | 218 | 218 | 216 | 217 | 272 |
Connecticut | 220 - 222 | 221 | 221 | 221 | 221 | 177 |
Delaware | 218 - 221 | 220 | 219 | 219 | 218 | 43 |
District of Columbia | 222 - 224 | 223 | 223 | 223 | 223 | 47 |
Florida | 216 - 220 | 218 | 217 | 216 | 216 | 972 |
Georgia | 217 - 221 | 219 | 218 | 217 | 218 | 624 |
Hawaii | 215 - 220 | 218 | 217 | 217 | 215 | 74 |
Idaho | 212 - 217 | 214 | 213 | 211 | 215 | 102 |
Illinois | 218 - 222 | 220 | 220 | 219 | 219 | 738 |
Indiana | 214 - 219 | 217 | 217 | 216 | 214 | 304 |
Iowa | 211 - 217 | 214 | 212 | 210 | 212 | 156 |
Kansas | 213 - 219 | 216 | 215 | 214 | 214 | 142 |
Kentucky | 211 - 217 | 214 | 213 | 211 | 212 | 202 |
Louisiana | 212 - 217 | 215 | 214 | 214 | 213 | 238 |
Maine | 212 - 217 | 215 | 214 | 213 | 215 | 53 |
Maryland | 221 - 224 | 222 | 222 | 221 | 222 | 296 |
Massachusetts | 221 - 224 | 223 | 223 | 222 | 220 | 294 |
Michigan | 216 - 220 | 218 | 218 | 217 | 218 | 511 |
Minnesota | 216 - 220 | 218 | 217 | 216 | 216 | 288 |
Mississippi | 210 - 215 | 213 | 212 | 209 | 210 | 155 |
Missouri | 214 - 218 | 216 | 215 | 214 | 213 | 276 |
Montana | 208 - 213 | 210 | 209 | 209 | 207 | 45 |
Nebraska | 210 - 216 | 213 | 211 | 210 | 212 | 118 |
Nevada | 211 - 218 | 215 | 214 | 211 | 210 | 162 |
New Hampshire | 214 - 219 | 217 | 217 | 215 | 213 | 55 |
New Jersey | 222 - 224 | 223 | 223 | 223 | 223 | 474 |
New Mexico | 209 - 215 | 212 | 211 | 207 | 208 | 94 |
New York | 219 - 221 | 220 | 220 | 220 | 219 | 1089 |
North Carolina | 216 - 220 | 218 | 218 | 217 | 217 | 518 |
North Dakota | 209 - 213 | 210 | 210 | 207 | 209 | 28 |
Ohio | 215 - 219 | 217 | 217 | 216 | 216 | 582 |
Oklahoma | 209 - 215 | 212 | 211 | 208 | 211 | 214 |
Oregon | 215 - 220 | 217 | 216 | 216 | 216 | 205 |
Pennsylvania | 217 - 221 | 219 | 219 | 219 | 218 | 583 |
Rhode Island | 213 - 220 | 217 | 217 | 215 | 216 | 50 |
South Carolina | 210 - 217 | 215 | 214 | 209 | 213 | 234 |
South Dakota | 209 - 214 | 211 | 208 | 209 | 212 | 41 |
Tennessee | 215 - 219 | 218 | 217 | 217 | 215 | 319 |
Texas | 218 - 221 | 220 | 219 | 219 | 219 | 1714 |
Utah | 210 - 216 | 213 | 211 | 209 | 211 | 195 |
Vermont | 211 - 217 | 215 | 215 | 212 | 213 | 33 |
Virginia | 220 - 223 | 222 | 222 | 219 | 221 | 394 |
Washington | 220 - 223 | 221 | 222 | 220 | 220 | 358 |
West Virginia | 209 - 212 | 210 | 209 | 207 | 207 | 66 |
Wisconsin | 213 - 217 | 215 | 214 | 213 | 213 | 289 |
Wyoming | 209 - 213 | 211 | 209 | 207 | 207 | 24 |
​U.S. Territories | 209 - 211 | 210 | 208 | 207 | 207 | 45 |
​​Studying Abroad | 222 - 224 | 223 | 223 | 223 | 223 | 112 |
​​​Commended | 209 - 211 | 210 | 208 | 207 | 207 |
If you’d like to see even more historical data, you can find cutoffs going back to 2008 in Compass’s National Merit Historical Cutoffs.
Why does each state have its own Semifinalist cutoff if the program is NATIONAL Merit?
This is always a hot button question. NMSC allocates the approximately 17,000 Semifinalists among states based on the annual number of high school graduates. That way, students across the nation are represented. It also means that there are very different qualifying standards from state to state. A Massachusetts student with a 220 might miss out on being a Semifinalist. If she lived 10 miles away in New Hampshire, she would qualify.
NMSC sets a target number of Semifinalists for a state. For example, California sees about 2,000 Semifinalists every year, Michigan 500, and Wyoming 25. In each state, NMSC determines the Selection Index that comes closest to matching its target number of Semifinalists. If 1,900 California students score 222 and higher and 2,050 score 221 or higher, then the Semifinalist cutoff would be 221 (this assumes that the target is exactly 2,000). Because score levels can get crowded, it is easy for cutoffs to move up or down a point even when there is minimal change in testing behavior or performance.
No Semifinalist cutoff can be lower than the national Commended level. Cutoffs for the District of Columbia and for U.S. students studying abroad are set at the highest state cutoff (typically New Jersey). The cutoff for students in U.S. territories and possessions falls at the Commended level each year. Boarding schools are grouped by region. The cutoff for a given region is the highest state cutoff within the region.
Why does the number of top scorers vary from year to year?
While there are changes in the number of students taking the PSAT/NMSQT, there can also be small flaws in test scaling that play a role. Prior to the digital PSAT, a single test form was seen by a large percentage of test takers. Something amiss with that single form could impact selection cutoffs across the country. The digital PSAT is constructed differently. Students receive unique form codes drawn from a large pool of problems. Scaled scores are generated based on the characteristics of those problems. In theory, this should make scores more stable. College Board’s early studies have found an extremely high correlation between the paper-and-pencil test and digital test. Still, even with its adaptive nature, the uncertainty remains as to whether the much shorter test can reliably score students at the 700-760 end of the scale.
What if I missed the PSAT because of illness or other legitimate reason?
You may still be able to enter the scholarship program by applying for Alternate Entry using an SAT score. Find information about last year’s process in Compass’s explanation of National Merit alternate entry.
When are National Merit Semifinalists announced?
The Commended cutoff becomes unofficially known by the end of April. The lists of Semifinalists are not distributed to high schools until the end of August. NMSC sets a press embargo on Semifinalist announcement until mid-September, but schools are allowed to notify students before that date. NMSC does not send Commended Student letters to high schools until mid-September. Compass will keep students updated on developments as those dates approach.
Do state and national percentiles indicate whether I will be a National Merit Semifinalist?
No! Approximately 1% of test takers qualify as Semifinalists each year, so it is tempting to view a 99th percentile score as indicating a high enough score — especially now that College Board provides students with percentiles by state. There are any number of flaws that rule out using percentiles as a quick way of determining National Merit status.
- Percentiles are based on section scores or total score, not Selection Index
- Percentiles are rounded. There is a large difference, from a National Merit perspective, between the top 0.51% and the top 1.49%
- Percentiles reveal the percentage of students at or below a certain score, but the “at” part is important when NMSC is determining cutoffs.
- The number of Semifinalists is based on the number of high school graduates in a state, not the number of PSAT takers. Percentiles are based on PSAT takers. States have widely varying participation rates.
- Most definitive of all: Percentiles do not reflect the current year’s scores! They are based on the prior 3 years’ performance. They are set even before the test is given. And if you are going to use prior history, why not use the completely accurate record of prior National Merit cutoffs rather than the highly suspect percentiles?
Entry requirements for National Merit versus qualifying for National Merit.
Your PSAT/NMSQT score report tells you whether you meet the eligibility requirements for the NMSP. In general, juniors taking the October PSAT are eligible. If you have an asterisk next to your Selection Index, it means that your answers to the entrance questions have made you ineligible. Your answers are conveniently noted on your score report. If you think there is an error, you will also find instructions on how to contact NMSC. Meeting the eligibility requirements simply means that your score will be considered. Approximately 1.4 million students enter the competition each year. Only about 53,000 students will be named as Commended Students, Semifinalists, Finalists, or Scholars. See National Merit Explained for more information.
What are my chances for 217 in MI?
V,
Based on how things are shaping up, I like your chances!
Hi Mr. Sawyer,
How was the cutoff in Massachusetts confirmed at 222? Is it for sure yet? Very surprising it would jump by 2.
I have a 221 so anxiously waiting.
John,
It is confirmed. I wasn’t expecting a 2-point increase, but it’s not that surprising, in retrospect. In the four “down” years for the current PSAT where the Commended level has been below 210, MA’s cutoff has been at 222, 222, 221, and 220. Arguably, the 220 is more of an outlier than the 222. It may represent a bounceback in testing post pandemic in the Bay State. [In the three “up” years, the cutoffs were 222, 223, and 223.]
Hi. Any word on cutoff for Louisiana? Is 214 good enough? Thanks.
ERW,
Louisiana’s cutoff is at 214 this year. You made it!
Thank you so much! So grateful that you can put us at ease. Still waiting on school to provide any info. So you are a lifesaver providing this information. 214! Louisiana getting smarter! Yay!
Any news from Rhode Island?
Not yet, Chris.
Any information on RI? Thank you.
Not yet, Todd.
I’m a senior in Kansas and appear to have qualified with 212.
Ben,
Have you received a Semifinalist letter from your school? I think Kansas’s NMSF cutoff will be higher than 212.
would a 220 in PA be considered good for NMSF?
Yes, John. Congratulations!
What do you think my chances are of NMSF as a 218 in Minnesota?
Stephanie,
I’m reasonably certain that you will qualify.
Hello, any update on PA? Is 219 confirmed?
Kolton,
PA is confirmed at 219.
Any updates on Indiana cutoff?
Nolan,
Nothing on Indiana yet.
Hello, Mr Sawyer!
Is there any update on whether or not an index of 215 will qualify for semifinalist status in Ohio? Thanks!
Joanne,
Unfortunately the Ohio cutoff this year is 216.
Will 221 be enough to qualify as a semi-finalist in Illinois?
Kaden,
Yes, a 221 will qualify in Illinois. This year’s cutoff is 219. Congratulations!
Thank you so much for your time and dedication! Greatly appreciated you are with us to walk with this long waited and inexplicit journey.
when is the announcement by NMSC expected to come? Do they announce the names of semifinalists? or it is just the cutoffs.
sreyasee,
Sometimes neither. NMSC does most of its Semifinalist communication via schools. High schools started receiving notifications last week, and more will make their way to principals and counselors this week. Some schools, however, choose to wait until the Semifinalist press release deadline of 9/13 (and some wait even longer). NMSC doesn’t itself release the names of Semifinalists. Instead, it releases state finalists to relevant press outlets. [It has only occasionally released cutoffs, sometimes unintentionally.] The catch is that those press outlets are under no obligation to report the information! It all boils down to receiving a letter from the school. That’s also how Semifinalists receive their online portal information for their Finalist applications.
Hi, I am from CA. My score is 220. Do I have a chance to be a semifinalist? Thank You!
Meg,
Unfortunately, we now know that CA’s cutoff is 221 this year.
Hello Mr. Sawyer. Is it confirmed confirmed that the Georgia cutoff is 218 or lower?
Yes.
Mr Sawyer
Any chance for 208 in utah. how did you confirm 209, student report or reditt
There is still a chance, although I think it will end up as 209.
Hi,
Is it confirmed that Colorado is a 217 or below?
Aiden,
Yes. Unless I list a specific reservation, all of the information can be considered confirmed.
My son qualified as a semifinalist in NC as a homeschooler. We have not received a Semifinalist letter. Will letters to homeschoolers be mailed at a later date, or is it possible that my son wound up on the list for the school at which he took the test?
RXF,
Homeschooler letters are mailed at the same time. My experience is that actual delivery can be erratic. NMSC will be glad to help you after the press release date of 9/13. I would give them a call at that point if the letter has not arrived. It shouldn’t go to the school where your son tested unless he was enrolled there, but I don’t want to say that it’s impossible.
Do you think 217 in Michigan will qualify?
I think it is 50/50 between 217 and 218. Hopefully we learn more soon.
Hi Art, what is the Pennsylvania score cut-off? Is a 222 qualifying? Also, where can the information about the PA cut-off be found officially? Thank you!
The PA cutoff is 219 this year, so a 222 qualifies as NMSF. If NMSC chooses to publish the cutoffs, it will not be until at least 9/13.
Do you think 210 will be commended? We are in TX so don’t think he has a chance for semi-finalist.
Sharmila,
Yes, the Commended cutoff is set nationally, and it is 207 this year. Your son will be a Commended Student!
Thank you so much. Appreciate the quick reply. Do we need to wait for official notification before adding it to college applications or is there any place to confirm that and add it before we receive official notification?
Sharmilla,
Since word should be released tomorrow (13th), there is no harm in waiting until it’s official. You can call NMSC to confirm your daughter’s status. Depending on where you live, you may find your daughter’s name listed online tomorrow. But I find that fewer and fewer publications bother to report Semifinalists any more.
If I got a 219 in Illinois does that qualify or no
Yes, Arya, any score at 219 or better will qualify in Illinois.
Art, any update from MO? Thanks!
Not yet, Jun.
Just a quick thank you for all your effort compiling this information! It is greatly appreciated and, as you know, helps alleviate some of the stresses of the process for students and families.
Thank you for the kind words, Robert.
Is Louisiana confirmed to be exactly 214? Or is it at most 214?
Louisiana’s cutoff is 214.
Should my son feel confident with a 212 in South Carolina? It looks like you are confident in a 210 cutoff?
Yes, your son’s 212 will qualify him for NMSF. Congratulations! We know that South Carolina’s cutoff is no higher than 210.
Congratulations to all of the SFs nationally.
With such large differences in cut-offs by state (as much as 5%+ differences for SF status) , this seems patently unfair to students in the states with higher cut-offs (CT, NJ, DC, MA, etc.). A 221 in CT does not qualify, but a 209 in UT does? A 222 in NJ out of luck, but a 207in NM is a SF.
Do colleges take note of what states NMSF / NMF are from and discount the “lower threshold” states ?
This is a debate that has raged for about 60 years, and NMSC has stuck to its methodology.
I have not heard of colleges making those distinctions. After all, a college doesn’t know if the UT student qualified with a 227 or a 209.
Since Holistic review applies to the way most top university admissions take, the standard test is a small part of it
And besides The possibility of 221 in CT not qualifying to be NMSF has a higher chance of getting a higher SAT score than 209 in UT!
I think it evens out in terms of who has more advantage in the admission process.
Final Thoughts. College admissions are not a fair process anyway!
I certainly understand your frustration, and I would probably feel the same way if I were in a situation in which my son did not qualify despite others qualifying with lower scores in other states. But if the issue is fairness, I would urge you to keep in mind that for the most part, the higher cutoff states are ranked much higher not only in education but also in median income, healthcare, physical and mental health, economic mobility and resources, and a whole host of other quality-of-life measures. An example would be my home state of Alabama, ranked 44 by USNWR in education and 44 overall when considering a number of economic, healthcare, etc. measures compared to New Jersey, which is ranked 2nd in education and 19th overall. So while some might think the SI cutoff variation between states unfair, the argument can be made that when looking at this in the context of the above factors, it would not be fair to hold every state to the same standard. Another way of saying it is that the average kid in New Jersey is much better off educationally and in every quality of life measure (except maybe college football!) because they were born and raised in New Jersey compared to the average kid in Alabama, Mississippi, New Mexico, Oklahoma, etc.
Also, it is worth keeping in mind that when looked at overall, NMSF students from New Jersey or other high-cutoff states will have higher index scores than students from lower-cutoff states, but there are plenty of students in lower-cutoff states who earned the same or better selection index scores than students from the higher-cutoff states. For example, my son attends a small town, fringe rural public high school in Alabama, and he and a young lady from his school both have a 223 SI, so they would have qualified in any state. They also have a classmate who scored 217 or 218, so he would have qualified in quite a number of states as well. Unless AOs at these colleges have the SIs, it would be unfair for them to assume a student from a lower cutoff state had a lower score than a student from a higher cutoff state.
Hi Art,
Thanks for your tireless work at compiling all of this info again this year! Is it true that the NMSF sends a list of semifinalists to US colleges? If so, do you know when this happens? I once read that it’s earlier than the typical press release date. Thanks!
Lori,
While I know that NMSC does send Semifinalist lists to colleges, I don’t know what the timing is. Sometimes there is confusion, because students receive marketing literature that implies Semifinalist outreach well before the release date (as in months before). It’s likely that those outreaches are done based on cutting College Board data based on PSAT scores rather than on pre-knowledge of Semifinalists.
Thanks for the response. The e-mail from highly selective schools has ramped up like crazy this week, so that’s what prompted my question.
Lori, good question! This week, my son has also been bombarded with emails from highly selective and Ivy League schools. We haven’t seen this much of a flurry of emails in a long time.